Love the podcast! You guys are my people🤗

Great podcast! Well researched and well told. John and Kay are really great together. I love their banter and they are very easy to listen to. A new favourite for me. Currently binge listening to all the episodes!

I just discovered this podcast because I feel like I’ve listened every other True Crime podcast out there. While I’m sorry I didn’t discover this podcast sooner, I have been listening back to back for days now! Kay, you are an amazing story teller. Your attention to detail and retelling if facts is unmatched. John, I love the repertoire amongst you both, and I love the love between you two!

I’m a new listener and am listening to all of the past podcasts. I love the hosts. The way they talk to each other is great. The research put into each podcast is very in depth. Fun and informative

I genuinely cannot get enough! They’re SO GREAT at story telling!

Love listening to this podcast . Well told stories and funny commentary between the two of them, love it . I just started listening 3 days ago and already on ep.18 as I drive for work about 10 -12 hours of the day. 5 stars all the way !!!

Kay and John are awesome together! It’s a perfect mix of info and commentary and I listen every week!

-Always Time for True Crime: A Podcast

The research, pace, delivery, content and chemistry between this adorable couple is fabulous! I find them insightful and delightful and am so happy I discovered this true crime podcast!

I love this couple. Kay and John are so loveable and clever.. their banter so funny, poignant and meaningful. Their podcasts have become my favourite crime podcasts... well researched stories told with compassion and wit. Those New Jersey accents just warm my heart! Great job you two. Forever fan from Toronto, Rosanne

I just listened to every single episode over the course of a month! True crime couple became a regular part of my commute to and from my classes...and really in every spare moment I had. Great stories, very well told, and you guys are so relatable. Thanks for the great content! -Toronto, Ontario

Hi! I love listening to podcasts, but it’s difficult to find that right balance: well-researched, but not boring, good rapport between the hosts, pleasant voices, just the right amount of discussion without getting sidetracked & losing the audience. You guys check all the boxes! When the two of you do chit-chat, it’s related to the case, and you are sharing insights and POV with the audience. You keep things moving along, never rushed, but with a relaxed, conversational tone. Great job!

I’ve been listening to you guys since you started :) one of my favourite podcasts! From Alberta, Canada

The writing is good, it is the reading, the obvious tedious reading that makes this an amateurish and unappealing true crime podcast. There are much, much better true crime podcasts out there.

You guys are amazing. Just discovered the show and have been binge listening. 💜

love! like a good book I make time for this podcast. as someone who loves scary movies (A, B, and beyond) this is right up my ally. I’m the one lounging at the beach learning about murders, kidnappings, and cults and proud of it.

John and Kay encourage participation in the podcast through their social media and are very appreciative when people take this to heart.

personally, I prefer the episodes that are more explanatory than story styled, and I hope that makes sense haha. but obviously I will listen either way.

I’m finishing up the most recent episode today and cannot wait for the next. what will I listen to at the gym? nothing is better motivation to get strong than learning about the world’s past and present killers : )

thanks John thanks Kay!

- Trista

I so love this podcast, the detail, the banter, the humour without being callous everything about it! I really enjoy that you guys have covered some cases I’ve never heard of....which with my true crime obsession is pretty rare! Keep up the good work you two!!

Jay and Kay describe really interesting stories and have a great back and forth on some of the theories and mysteries surrounding them.

I love the couple- love the accent- jersey shore yeah?... super thorough and so damn interesting to listen to- I just about screamed when the first part of the White House was over because I don’t want to wait another week to hear the rest from them - i want it sooner but I know it won’t happen. I’ll just have to be patient like everybody else Man...